Hi mustclime,
Reading through the thread I am not quite sure what it is that you have against German Armour...so I thought that I would just write this piece.....in support of it
Yes alot of it was destroyed by the crews when they were forced to retreat rather than to let a complete tank fall into enemy hands due to lack of spares or simply fuel.......you specifically mention the ' M26 Purshing tank' I think that you mean the P
ershing tank.......having looked it up....it is not really a particularly good tank.......
.....Development of the M26 during World War II was prolonged by a number of factors, the most important being opposition to the tank from Army Ground Forces (AGF). As a result, only the
initial 20 M26 (T26E3) tanks deployed to Europe in January 1945 saw combat in World War II.[1] The M26 and its improved derivative, the M46 Patton, both saw more combat in Korea.
The M26 was underpowered and mechanically unreliable and so was withdrawn from Korea in 1951, in favor of the M46, which had a more powerful engine.[2] The lineage of the M26 continued with the M47 Patton, and was reflected in the new designs of the later M48 Patton and M60 Combat Tank.
....................
Hardly a glowing report.....
.
For its time...the German armour specifically the Tiger 1 ,the Panther and the King Tiger....have to be classed as TRULY outstanding vehicles....this is a Quote from the Soviets about the Panther......
.
Soviets held Panthers in
high regard and considered captured Panther to be a prize.Captured Panthers were then given to successful crews as a kind of reward.In order to keep them running captured German mechanics were pressed into service and in 1944, Panther’s manual was printed in Russian for distribution among tank crews. Captured vehicles temporarily remained in theiroriginal colors but with markings of their new owners. Later, some were repainted in dark green and were marked withlarge tactical markings and white stars for indentification purposes.
.............So if you retreat..destroy the tank rather than let the commies get it and just fill it up with fuel and then use it against you !
Another quote...about the 'BAD' Panther......
Panzerkampfwagen V Panther was a very successful design and two could be produced in the same time as a single Panzerkampfwagen VI Tiger tank. Panther revolutionized tank designs and influenced post-war western tank designs and is considered to be the first MBT (Main Battle Tank). Overall, Panther proved to be an excellent weapon when commanded and operated by people like Ernst Barkmann. Panther was liked by its crews, best summarized in statement by Lieutenant Berger of "Grossdeutschland" - "We were shot three times - I owed my life to the Panther…".
After the war, many French Army tank units were equipped with Panthers (eg. 503rd Tank Battalion in Mourmelon had 50 Panthers in 1947 and 501rd Tank Battalion used Panthers from 1946 to 1950). Other post-war users included Bulgaria (Bulgarian Panthers), Czechoslovakia, Hungary, Romania and Yugoslavia.
After the war, modified Panther’s 75mm KwK 42 L/70 gun was produced by French as 75mm DEFA and CN75-50 gun. It was used by them in a number of light tanks (eg. AMX 13) and armored cars (eg. EBR 75). Also, Israelis used the gun to upgrade their M50 Super Sherman.
Between 1949 and 1952, French also worked on AMX-50 tank, which was heavily influenced by the Panther (and powered by Maybach engine), but it didn’t enter production in favour of American M47 Patton Medium Tank..
...............................So they are not THAT BAD.......there were also outstanding commanders...Carius, Wittmann, Barkman and of course the number 1 tank killer Kurt Knispel
The TIGER 1.......a LEGEND...and it always will be.....everyone who is remotely interested in tanks knows the Tiger.....at least 6 Shermans sent to kill one and recon to lose 5 of them to do it , even in confined spaces like the Bocage.....Sherman...AKA ' The Tommy Cooker' by the Germans and also as 'The Ronson,by the British crews because it' Lights first Time, Every Time'.....one penetration shot and bye bye Sherman.
The German tanks were Very expensive to make and made in too few numbers.......BUT they could fight....... Guderian himself said..."Wir werden Sieger - durch unsren Tiger" (We will be victorious - thanks to our Tigers)
Just my 2 cents worth as the saying goes......Yes I am a bit biased as I like the German tanks....the only
other ones..are the T34..for being so revolutionary a design..and the British sherman firefly for its gun.......
By the way tests were carried out by the German army and having the driven spocket the Front DOES actually give better grip..but I accept that it also means that the transmission has to go through the crew compartment, unless you put the whole transmission at the front as well.
Alb