If you have Amazon Prime, check out

Do you know of any good tank related movies or simple decent war movies? Post them here for all of us to enjoy!
Meter rat
Warrant Officer 1st Class
Posts: 1619
Joined: Wed Aug 05, 2020 7:33 pm
Location: By the sea in Argyle and Bute

Re: If you have Amazon Prime, check out

Post by Meter rat »

michaelwhittmann wrote: Tue Jul 01, 2025 11:49 pm You guys are bayonetting a dead body. The guy survived 3 years on the Eastern Front.; should get a medal just for that.
That is because he was being paraded, wined and dined by the high heid yins, back in Germany.

Many others, ordinary soldiers, and tank crews, also survived lengthy periods on the Eastern Front. Are they also not worthy of medals?

Try reading about Richard Freiherr von Rosen. He Survived the war, and went on to be Panzer-Brigade commander in the Bundeswehr. He used his experience gained, from both the Eastern Front, and Western Front to develop a lot of the modern tactics used to day. This was especially true of the immediate post war threat from Russia and the ensuing Cold War. Arguably a far better Commander.

I dislike random, meaningless statements like “Michael Whittmann of course”. To me it has no context in the discussion. I have not watched any of the episodes so I am unable to understand the statement.
User avatar
michaelwhittmann
Corporal
Posts: 383
Joined: Mon Dec 04, 2023 7:03 pm

Re: If you have Amazon Prime, check out

Post by michaelwhittmann »

Rourke's Drift/ Zululand / 2 days in January 1879
150 British soldiers and Natal Native Contingent vrs 3-4,000 Zulus
For 2 days the British Garrison fought the Zulus to a standstill. The Zulus withdrew.
2 officers/ 8 rankers/ and 1 NNC were awarded the Victoria Cross.
They were wined and dined and met the Queen at Balmoral.

Why not 135 VCs? I say 135 since at that time, the VC could not be awarded posthumously.
15 were killed.

It's the nature of medals/awards, Some get em; some don't.
Politics/ propaganda/ knowing the right people; that's part of it.

A statement may have no meaning to you. That doesn't make it meaningless.
1st NJ Tank Squadron
HL Sherman
HL King Tiger
HL Panzer III
HL Tiger I
HL Panther
HL Pershing
Tongde Chaffee
Taigen T34/ 85
Post Reply

Return to “Movies”