Page 2 of 2

Re: Being Selfishy

Posted: Wed Sep 23, 2009 10:40 pm
by xrad
:'( :'( :'(


vote?

Re: Being Selfishy

Posted: Sat Sep 26, 2009 8:30 pm
by fv432
Xrad i like your idea and have seen this over the pond on hobby havoc
still up to matt though ;) ;)

ive put up a poll and voted to kick things off

all thats really needed is tiger/ m26/ bulldog/  pz3/ pz4/ kv1 and jagdpanther

stug would fall under pz3 imho

just my thoughts ;)

Re: Being Selfishy

Posted: Sun Sep 27, 2009 7:23 am
by Mackem
RC Panzerketten is laid out in a similar way.
Matt's problem would be re-locating all of the existing builds into their new homes.
Depending upon the underlying architecture of the forums software this could be a fairly simple fix, or it could create a lot of work. For this reason I wont vote until Matt has had a chance to assess the pro's and cons.

Cheers
John

Re: Being Selfishy

Posted: Sun Sep 27, 2009 10:42 am
by Matdragon
Pros-

=makes it easier for people who can't be bothered to use the search function to find what they are looking for

cons-

=divides the builds up even further

=would end up having to do it for the tamiya builds as well

=would require lots of time to move threads over

=people would get confused as to where they would put conversions ect

all in all i don't think it should happen, but ill leave it to the vote.

you say Hobbyhavoc and panzerketten have it ? you seen how 'small' hobbyhavoc's posts are and it doesnt seem to be growing, we have been around for about a year and a bit, and have over tripled hobbyhavocs post and they have been around for.. oh years and years and years lol . (we'll catch up with panzerketten one day, but i fear their are more tankers in germany who will use the german forum making it harder to catch up :P a target then! :D)

anyway ill let the vote do the talking.

Matt

Re: Being Selfishy

Posted: Mon Sep 28, 2009 12:40 am
by xrad
Hey Guys, THANKS for at least considering the idea. If vote turns out 'yes'....just try it out in HL section. See if it's a PITA or works out.